All-Inclusive Hotel or Small Independent Lodge?

As all-inclusive holidays are becoming more popular in The Gambia, I thought it might be interesting to take a look at their perceived benefits and drawbacks. All-inclusive holidays are often marketed as the ultimate hassle-free vacation option. With the promise of having all your needs catered for within the price, it’s no wonder that this package deal is a popular choice among tourists seeking a no-fuss break from their daily routines. However, these packages may not be the idyllic solution they’re made out to be. Today let’s explore why all-inclusive holidays might or might not live up to their enticing advertisements.

Let’s start with the pros!


All-inclusive holidays offer an enticing array of advantages that appeal to a wide audience. They promise a hassle-free travel experience with a controlled budget. The core principle is convenience; from the moment you book your trip, almost every aspect of your vacation is taken care of. This comprehensive approach to travel is particularly attractive for those looking to unwind without the burden of constant decision-making and additional costs.


Because of the financial predictability it offers, travellers can pay one upfront price that encompasses almost everything. By doing so, you can effectively avoid the shock of post-vacation credit card bills, allowing for a more relaxing and carefree holiday experience. Especially for families, this means less stress over daily expenditures and more budget left for souvenirs or saving up for the next adventure.

With meals and beverages included, there’s no need to search for restaurants or worry about the cost of dining out every day. They typically include a variety of dining options, catering to different tastes and meal preferences. This can be beneficial for those with dietary restrictions because it adds confidence they will be accommodated throughout their stay.

Cater for families

Activities and entertainment are another pro. Many resorts offer a wide range of options, from fitness classes and water sports to live shows and kids’ clubs. Guests can try new experiences without having to make separate arrangements or venture far from the comfort of their accommodations. This is particularly beneficial for those travelling with children, as it provides instant access to entertainment that keeps the younger ones occupied and enthralled.


Furthermore, security and safety are enhanced within the confines of an all-inclusive resort. This sense of security is important for travellers, especially those unfamiliar with the language or customs of their destination. The self-contained environment of a resort can offer peace of mind to those concerned with navigating foreign environments independently.

In summary, an all-inclusive holiday has the potential to eliminate many of the typical travel stresses, allowing tourists to indulge in a rejuvenating retreat. With meals, accommodation, entertainment, and numerous activities enveloped in one fixed price, travellers can enjoy the convenience and relaxation that this type of vacation affords, ultimately creating a memorable and worry-free escape.

And now the cons!

The Illusion of an all-inclusive holiday

One of the core attractions of an all-inclusive holiday in The Gambia is the perception of endless food and drink. Yet, the reality can be quite different. The “all you can eat and drink” mindset may lead to lower-quality meals where variety and authenticity take a backseat. To cater to a wide range of palates, dishes are often international rather than local. Causing a destination’s unique culinary profile to be lost amidst generic offerings.

Hidden Costs

While the initial payment for an all-inclusive holiday suggests that you won’t have to dip into your wallet for the rest of the trip. This isn’t always the case ( Source Wikipedia ). Extra charges might be lurking around the corner for premium drinks. A la carte restaurant meals, exclusive activities, and special events. These additional expenses can accumulate, detracting from the perceived value of the upfront all-inclusive price.

Limited Exploration Incentive

When you’ve already paid for all your meals and drinks within the resort, there’s little financial incentive to venture outside and explore local businesses. This can lead to semi-self-imposed confinement to the resort. This causes travellers to miss out on authentic experiences. Such as dining at local restaurants, participating in regional traditions, and supporting local economies.

One-Size-Fits-All Approach

The resorts often operate on a one-size-fits-all model, aiming to please the average guest. This homogenization means personalized experiences are scarce. Tourists seeking genuine interaction with the local culture or a tailored holiday experience might find this approach disappointing.

Environmental and Social Impact

The model can also have detrimental effects on local communities and the environment. As enterprises strive to meet the constant demands of being full, ecological sustainability may be compromised, and resources can be over-utilized. Additionally, while they do provide employment, there are concerns about the quality of these jobs and whether the profits contribute fairly to the local economy.

Quality Versus Quantity

Packed sunbeams on an all inclusive holiday

Arghh, no sunloungers left!

While having access to a variety of amenities seems appealing, the quality of these amenities may not be as high as expected.

Crowded pools, overbooked spa facilities, and rushed entertainment can diminish the overall enjoyment.

Resorts may focus more on providing numerous options rather than ensuring that each service is of superior quality.

Crowds and Cookie-Cutter Experiences

Many all-inclusive resorts are quite large, and during peak travel seasons, they can be overcrowded. With crowds of tourists, finding a poolside lounge chair becomes a competitive sport. And there’s always a race to reserve spots for activities that are limited in availability. This mass tourism approach often leads to a lack of authentic, personal experiences for guests.

Dining on a Schedule

Unlike choosing your dining times and places on a non-packaged holiday. An all-inclusive stay may require you to adhere to strict meal times and book reservation slots in advance. This structure can make your vacation feel regimented and can conflict with the spontaneous, leisurely nature of travel that many seek.

The Drink Dilemma

Too much alcohol

Danger in overindulgence

Unlimited alcohol is a strong selling point of all-inclusive packages, but it also has its drawbacks.

The temptation to overindulge is hard for many to resist when it’s already been paid for, possibly leading to unsavoury behaviour by fellow guests that can put a damper on your relaxing retreat.

Impersonal Service

With the volume of guests to attend to, staff at all-inclusive resorts may not have the time to offer the personalized service that smaller hotels or specialized vacations provide. This can result in a lack of attention to finer details that can make or break a holiday experience.

In conclusion, all-inclusive holidays can certainly offer convenience, but they might not be the most fulfilling or value-for-money options for every traveller. The apparent ease of an all-in setting often hides extra costs. It promotes less exploration and can fall short of providing a genuine local experience. Those seeking authentic interactions, cultural immersion, and personalized experiences may not find what they’re looking for within the confines of an all-inclusive package. As with any type of vacation, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons of your travel priorities.

So, an all-inclusive resort or a small independent lodge?

Staying at small independent lodges, especially in a destination like The Gambia, offers a unique opportunity to connect with local culture and contribute positively to the environment. These lodges often provide a more authentic experience, as they are typically built and managed with a deep respect for the local community and traditions. They tend to employ residents. This supports the regional economy and also offers a chance to engage with locals in a meaningful way.

Since small lodges have fewer guests, they offer personalized service and attention to detail that large resorts cannot match, ensuring a memorable and intimate stay. Additionally, smaller accommodations are usually more mindful of their environmental footprint, utilizing sustainable practices and integrating with their natural surroundings, which large-scale resorts often overlook in favour of volume and convenience. By choosing a small locally run accommodation you will enjoy a culturally rich and environmentally responsible experience. Read our peace of mind promise here!

At the end of the day, the choice is yours and we hope you choose small independent accommodations in The Gambia, like ours!

Scroll to Top